Post by Islamic Revival on Mar 6, 2006 9:15:59 GMT -5
Let me clarify things again. What we are calling for, is the system of the caliphate as presented by the Prophet Muhammad(saw). The prophet(saw)did predict the reestablishment of the caliphate and he also predicted that it would be the same as he had set up.
What u are suggesting is, that the caliphate is the system of monrchy by a few incidents quoting them out of context and twisting the realities. You are referring to some history incidents. You dare not refer to the the time of Prophet(saw) and the Khulfaeh rashdeen( the righteous caliphs). Why is it that when u are referring to caliphate u refer to some very very specific incidents. And on the basis of these incidents you reject caliphate as monarchy. Where as you know that very well that what the real system is .
As for as the system of monarchy goes i would like to make an important point. We see the four imams accounting the ruler, and the Ummah backing them. Where in monarchy does accountability take place? Had that been monarchy, the will of the monarch had been implemented and the people have kept quiet. This goes on to show that the Ummah in general had a clear understanding of Islam and its systems and that these systems were properly in place. If someone went against Islam he was accounted strongly.
What u are suggesting is, that the caliphate is the system of monrchy by a few incidents quoting them out of context and twisting the realities. You are referring to some history incidents. You dare not refer to the the time of Prophet(saw) and the Khulfaeh rashdeen( the righteous caliphs). Why is it that when u are referring to caliphate u refer to some very very specific incidents. And on the basis of these incidents you reject caliphate as monarchy. Where as you know that very well that what the real system is .
As for as the system of monarchy goes i would like to make an important point. We see the four imams accounting the ruler, and the Ummah backing them. Where in monarchy does accountability take place? Had that been monarchy, the will of the monarch had been implemented and the people have kept quiet. This goes on to show that the Ummah in general had a clear understanding of Islam and its systems and that these systems were properly in place. If someone went against Islam he was accounted strongly.